How accurate is the film bloody sunday

How selmas bloody sunday became a turning point in the. Bloody sunday and mlks calls for all to join a second demonstration in selma led to an even bigger march, which included clergymen and ordinary citizens of various races, two days later. The impetus and choices for the film are discussed at further length greengrass states that it was crucial this was a joint venture of sorts between the brits greengrass himself is british and the irish, and believes that bloody sunday can help in the attempt to heal old wounds, rather than inflame them for example, british military. Bloody sundays truths and tragedies media the guardian. Whatever truly happened that day, all sides are agree that bloody sunday marked a major negative turning point in the fortunes of northern ireland. Time has offered the troubles perspective, investigation and popculture outlets u2. Few today take the report of the widgery tribunal seriously as an accurate factual analysis of what happened on bloody sunday.

Paul greengrass film bloody sunday, which shared the golden bear at. Two films mark thirtieth anniversary of bloody sunday. The drama shows the events through the eyes of ivan cooper, the protestant stormont member of parliament who was a central organizer of the northern ireland civil rights association march in derry on 30 january 1972. When you make a film about a real event, you have to deal with not only the artistic decisions of how to film it but also with the obligation to.

The film is not slanted in any way,the british army lost it on bloody sunday and killed unarmed civilians and have tried for years to cover up their crime and this is not the only instance as something similar happened in ballymurphy,a housing estate in west belfast and people are still demanding some form of justice for the murder of innocent civilians yet again. Some images display only as thumbnails outside the library of congress because of rights considerations, but you have access to larger size images on site. The events of bloody sunday are allowed to speak for themselves, increasing the dramatic impact of the film. There is no such thing as a perfectly accurate film, but it is the best.

It does not move the longrunning debate on the question of who started the shooting. Coopers moving and entirely accurate comment that bloody sunday would act as as a powerful recruiting agent for the ira lacks any historical value because we have not been told. In an attempt to avoid being subjective, the film goes beyond the typical portrayal of the british as heartless murderers and gives them a voice during this. A sense of immediate and present reality permeates every scene. My notion, all the same, is that sunday bloody sunday is about people who suffer from psychic amputation, not civility, and that this film is not an affirmation but a tragedy. Bloody sunday is a 2002 britishirish film about the 1972 bloody sunday shootings in derry, northern ireland. Send us your views on paul greengrasss film, bloody sunday. Sunday bloody sunday probably was a lot more groundbreaking back at the start of the 1970s due its themes of homosexuality and bisexuality, but because of how commonplace the topics are in today. Bloody sunday doesnt offer much in the way of developing relationships between its characters and audience, but if you want a gritty, wellacted and historically accurate drama, then its your.

Shocking depictions that do nothing to help 30year search for the. Selma written by paul webb with uncredited input from duvernay, selma tells the riveting story of how king and other. Alternatively, you can purchase copies of various types through library of. The film portrays catholics to be the sole victims in the struggle between unionists and nationalists. But the entire film for me was a difficult period because when i first saw it, i viewed the film with the relatives of those who died on bloody sunday, and the film itself is so realistic from. A london doctor, played by peter finch, a divorced woman, played by glenda jackson, and a young man, played by murray head, they are both in love with. It tells the story of a freespirited young bisexual artist played by head and his simultaneous relationships with a divorced female recruitment job consultant jackson and a gay male jewish doctor finch. Bloody sunday protest march, selma, alabama, march 7, 1965. It is a story about three people in a love triangle. The film explored the murder of black youth, stephen lawrence, and the shoddy investigations done by the metropolitan police.

An accurate version of events london evening standard. And finally ive heard that the director took some liberties in the bloody sunday scene. There are two crucial points about paul greengrasss bloody sunday film that need to be made in the light of the controversy it is already. In an interesting movie, the film never gives us a full look at bonnie and clyde until the end, offering only glimpses at them throughout the film. U2 bono on the meaning of sunday bloody sunday live dublin croke park 27 june 1987 duration. That judgment was enlisted to carry the critical defense of the movie. The impact of bloody sunday on northern ireland divisions. Bloody sunday director paul greengrass does an excellent job at crafting a documentary feel for the story, complete with grainy film, jumpy shots, wavering sound and naturally gray light. Paul greengrasss directorial style seems to be a deliberate choice of minimalism. James nesbitts character, ivan cooper, states, all civil rights people are catholics bloody sunday. On the anniversary of bloody sunday, look back at the assault on civil rights marchers in selma, alabama, that led to the voting rights act. In a carnival atmosphere, a peaceful antiinternment march began, only to end tragically a few hours later when thirteen unarmed marchers were shot dead by the british army. Is this film an accurate depiction of the days events. This film is based on the events of bloody sunday a day during the conflict between the english and the irish in the 1970s, in which regiments of the british army went around parts of ireland.

Pettus bridge from selma into montgomery on sunday to recreate a pivotal moment in the civil rights movement on its. Is the film bloody sunday by paul greengrass very accurate. He followed it with bloody sunday, 2002, based on the 1972 bloody sunday shootings, during which british soldier shot some irish antiinterment activists. Does the love triangle between harry, kitty, and michael have any basis in reality. The doctor and the woman know about each other, but dont seem. Two films mark thirtieth anniversary of bloody sunday by paul bond 21 february 2002 on january 30, 1972, soldiers from the first parachute regiment of the british army opened fire on unarmed civil. How accurate are the depictions of the characters in the film based on accounts of them. Bloody sunday is, if nothing else, a very powerful film and, depending on which side youre on ideologically, can move you to tears or incite you with rage. Bloody sunday 2002 bloody sunday 2002 bloody sunday 2002 bloody sunday 2002 bloody sunday 2002 full movie bloody sunday 2002 full movie bloody sunday 2002 full movie a dramatization of the irish civil rights protest march and subsequent massacre by british troops on january 30, 1972. The attention to detail in the film comes through her as the limp is historically accurate at this point. The 1972 bloody sunday shootings in derry, northern ireland.

Bloody sunday focuses on one of the saddest events in that long, sad war between brothers. Bloody sunday is one view of what happened that day, a very effective one. However, whenever we see bonnie, she is shown to have a bad limp said to be from a car accident. Sunday bloody sunday is a 1971 british drama film written by penelope gilliatt, directed by john schlesinger and starring murray head, glenda jackson, peter finch and peggy ashcroft. Martin luther king called for civil rights supporters to come to selma for a second march.

Having served with the british army in northern ireland many years later i found the atmosphere and the general appearance and manner of the paras extremely accurate, as i have seen many films about ireland when trying to portray british soldiers they unfortunately could of done a little better. Come sunday chiwetel ejiofor excels as a preacher forced to rethink his faith in this cleareyed look at power struggles in the evangelical community. When members of congress pressured him to restrain the march until a court could rule on whether the protesters deserved federal protection, king found himself torn between their requests for patience. Bloody sunday in russia, 1905 the library of congress. If an image is displaying, you can download it yourself. The dialogue might be hard to follow between strong accents and a shifting aural perspective but the result is so realistic that the abrupt ringing of the. Among other significant errors may cites is that bloody sunday, in which state and local police attacked protesters, was not immediately shown on tv, as the film depicts. It became known as bloody sunday and these are the victims. Selma does a magnificent job of recreating important historical scenes, such as the events of 7 march 1965 known as bloody sunday in which alabama state troops.

January 30, 1972, in derry, northern ireland, is a day that will forever be remembered in ireland as bloody sunday. Contrary to who jesus christ is and his teachings, roman catholics and protestants have been fighting for centuries in ireland. The bloody sunday wound will never heal while films like these are. Sunday bloody sunday was a film that had me searching for something more. Little wonder, therefore, that his film, bloody sunday, and ours, sunday, were very different. Based on the testimonies from both soldiers and marchers, as published in don mullans book eyewitness bloody sunday, paul greengrass film courts controversy from the. Although produced by granada television as a tv film, it premiered at the sundance film festival on 16 january, a few days before its screening on itv on 20 january, and then in selected london cinemas from 25 january. I saw this film about 2 years ago, and was extremely impressed with the realism of the film. If a picture is worth a thousand words, a movies worth a million. First, the film failed to broach the issue of religion using a wellrounded approach.